QC Inspection Services Logo  
   
 

COMET 250 White Light Scanner

Since August 2000, QC Inspection Services has offered scanning services using the COMET 250 white light scanner. Much of the following information pertaining to the capabilities of the COMET 250 was obtained from the Steinbichler website.

Comet 250 Scan

COMET Measuring System

Based on white light triangulation, the systems are specialized for applications ranging from small, precision components to hand-sculpted models as well as large tools, dies and vehicles. Using patented fringe projection techniques, COMET produces very dense, accurate point cloud data which permits rapid surface and tool path generation.

COMET digitizes surface geometry patch by patch with ‘point-and-shoot’ ease of use. The various patches of high-density data are aligned using various techniques, making it a flexible system.

Software (Win NT) functionality includes high-speed point cloud processing, polygon model generation, surface reconstruction, alignment to CAD and color-map inspection reports. Import data to any CAD system.

COMET Optical 3D Digitizing System

The Comet 250 has a Measuring Volume Per View of 230 x 180 x 250 mm, and accuracy of +/- 0.06mm.

Each view or "scan" measures 420,000 X-Y-Z points in 30 seconds. With large objects or objects with complex surface geometry it is necessary to take several measurement views to ensure that all surfaces are recorded. There is no limit to the number of views, or "patches" that can be recorded per object.

Global Alignment of Digitized Point Cloud "Patches"

COMET digitizes surface geometry patch by patch with ‘point-and-shoot’ ease of use. The various patches of high-density data are aligned using various techniques, making it an extremely flexible system.

After the scan, the patches are globally aligned, or transformed together in the COMET software to form one 3-dimensional point cloud. The 3-D point cloud can vary in size, up to millions of measured points. The coordinates of each of these points are identified by the system and can be output as a dense point cloud, poly-line cross-sections or polygonal model.

Formats include AC, ASCII, TXT, DXF, VDA, IGES, OBJ, and STL. Software also allows alignment of point cloud data to CAD models and computation of graphic color-map inspection reports.

Three Levels of Processing

There are three distinct levels of processing that can be performed on scan data once it has been aligned into a single point cloud.

The first stage is direct application of the point cloud in a CAD comparison based 3-D inspection. Because this type of comparison does not require any manual editing of the 3-D data (with the possible exception of a quick removal of small marker added to aid alignment), this application offers the quickest turnaround time. 3-D CAD comparison is also possible with more fully processed data.

The second stage is creation of a watertight polygon model, typically exported in STL format. STL files are suitable for N/C programming for many milling machines and are often used for rapid prototyping. Processing applied at this stage ranges from simple filling of gaps in the surface not captured by the COMET scanner, usually due to an obstructed view, to sophisticated edge sharpening operations which restore feature qualities in the part beneath the precision level of the COMET.

The third and most advanced stage of scan data processing is the creation of a complete NURBS surface representation. NURBS surface are the best suited format for machining purposes and allow addition of features through import of industry standard formats such as IGES and STEP into 3-D CAD packages.
Optical Setup and Principle of Triangulation

COMET 250 Scanner - Traingular Print

Optical scanning, whether using a laser stripe or white light fringe pattern is passed on the principle of triangulation. In the diagram above the light source at the bottom projects a point seen by the camera at the top. Because the angles and distances between the light source and camera are fixed, and the direction of the light ray is known, the depth of the surface where the light hits it can be calculated. In the image above, if the car door were moved closer the highlighted spot would be seen further down by the camera, and a closer depth would be calculated.

A white light scanner like the COMET 250 which captures nearly half a million points in one shot is a little more complex, but the basic idea is the same.
FAQ's Regarding the White Light Scanner:
Q) WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN WHITE LIGHT AND LASER?

A) Obviously there is a vast difference in the properties of the two light sources, but as they relate to measurement results there is very little difference. Mathematically they both utilize triangulation algorithms which inherently have the same characteristics for accuracy and resolution - they are both light projection techniques. The user's choice in utilizing one of the light projection techniques is determined by the application. Laser light is focused in a single beam or sheet illuminating a limited area at one time and therefore can only measure a certain number of points that fall inside of the laser point or "stripe".

White light, as utilized by the Comet system, is able to illuminate a "region" at a time. Each scan within this region produces 420,000 XYZ data points! By projecting a coded pattern of shadows within that region, many more points can be measured than can be done with laser light. This means a far faster scanning system.

Q) IS WHITE LIGHT BETTER THAN LASER?

A) A laser system can be constructed at a far lower cost due to lower component cost and simple design. They are however substantially slower that white light systems.

Q) WHICH IS MORE ACCURATE?

A) We have developed systems utilizing both light sources and have not experienced any accuracy benefit with either. Laser system are more susceptible to noisy data with highly reflective surfaces but there are techniques for overcoming this problem.

Q) WHAT IS THE MEASURING ENVELOPE FOR THE COMET 250?

A) Each "patch" is approximately 8 inches squared. If the part is larger than 8 inches, multiple scans will need to be taken. Each scan would need to "overlap" the previous scan for overall part alignment.

Q) HOW MUCH ACCURACY IS LOST WHEN SCANNING LARGER PARTS?

A) This is almost impossible to quantify in a general fashion. There are virtually dozens of techniques for scanning large parts and each could result in different variations. Again, the optimum scanning technique to be applied is determined by the applications requirements. We consistently achieve accuracies of 0.1mm bumper to bumper on a full size car model and 0.25mm on the wing of an aircraft at Boeing.

Q) WHAT TYPE OF PARTS IS THIS SYSTEM BEST SUITED FOR?

A) The Comet 250 is ideal for parts from tightly toleranced motorcycle parts and injection molding tools, to low accuracy applications like foam seats and plastic toys.

For more information, please call:

(800) 959-0632 or (952) 895-1150


QC Inspection Services, Inc. (HQ):
11975 Portland Ave. S., Suite 102, Burnsville, MN 55337
Phone: (952) 895-1150     Fax: (952) 895-1152
eng@qcinspect.com     www.qcinspect.com